Call Us On:

Chepstow: 01291 639280

Newport: 01633 358888

Bristol: 0117 233 8744

Resolving a dispute with a builder

20 November 2026

Resolving a dispute with a builder

I’m Renting My Home – What Are My Rights?

For many homeowners, a building project represents one of the largest investments they will ever make. It may be the extension you have spent years saving for, a loft conversion to accommodate a growing family, or ground-floor accommodation needed for a loved one with health or mobility issues. Whatever the reason, you enter the project with the expectation that the work will be completed to a professional standard, within an agreed timescale and budget.

Unfortunately, building projects do not always go to plan. Delays, defective workmanship, unexpected costs and disagreements over what was agreed, can quickly turn an exciting project into a stressful and expensive experience. What starts as a minor issue can escalate into a dispute that leaves homeowners living in an unfinished property while facing significant financial uncertainty.

When problems arise, it is important to understand your legal rights and the options available to resolve the dispute. Seeking advice from a specialist solicitor at an early stage can often prevent matters from escalating and place you in a much stronger position if court proceedings become necessary.

Grounds for dispute

Poor workmanship – where the finished work falls below the standard that was agreed or that a reasonable person would expect from a competent builder, is a common cause for dispute. This might include structural defects, poor finishes, incorrect installation of fixtures, or the use of unsuitable materials.

Delays – disagreements also arise over delays. While some delays are unavoidable, particularly where adverse weather or supply chain issues are involved, others occur because of poor project management, inadequate staffing, or the builder taking on more work than they can handle.

Disputed costs  –  another common source of conflict. Homeowners may receive invoices for work they did not authorise or find the final bill considerably higher than anticipated. Equally, builders may argue that changes requested during the project justify increased costs, even where those changes were undocumented.

Incomplete work – disputes can also arise where work remains incomplete, the builder abandons the project altogether, or fails to rectify defects. In some cases, homeowners may discover problems months after the work has been completed, raising questions about responsibility and the cost of putting matters right.

Your rights as a consumer

When you employ a builder, you are entitled to expect the work will be carried out with reasonable care and skill. The work should match what was agreed, be completed within a reasonable time (if no completion date has been specified), and any agreed price should be honoured unless legitimate variations have been agreed.

Even where no formal written contract exists, legal rights may still arise from quotations, emails, text messages, plans, invoices and the conduct of the parties.

Relevant law

For most homeowners, the Consumer Rights Act 2015 provides significant protection in a building dispute. It requires traders providing services to carry out their work with reasonable care and skill, and usually within a reasonable time. Where those standards are not met, consumers may have legal remedies against the builder.

The terms of the building contract are also important. Whether the agreement is a written contract or a simpler exchange of correspondence, the agreed scope of work, price, timescale and specification will often determine each party’s obligations.

In some cases, a builder may have negligently carried out work that falls below the standard expected of a reasonably competent contractor, resulting in safety risks or property damage.

Misrepresentation may arise where a builder makes false or misleading statements to persuade you to enter into the contract, such as claiming to have particular qualifications or experience, promising to use premium-quality materials but substituting cheaper alternatives, or falsely assuring you that planning permission or Building Regulations approval is unnecessary.

There may also be breaches of statutory duties relating to construction work. For example, building work may fail to comply with the Building Regulations, health and safety requirements, or other legal standards governing residential construction. Where these issues arise, the implications can extend beyond the cost of repairs and may affect the safety, value or future saleability of your property.

Remedies

The appropriate remedy will depend on the nature of the dispute, the terms of your agreement with the builder, and the losses you have suffered. While every case is different, the law provides a range of remedies designed either to put defective work right or compensate you for the financial consequences.

In some situations, the most practical solution is for the builder to rectify the defective work. However, where workmanship has been particularly poor or trust has been lost, homeowners are often reluctant to allow the original contractor back into their property. A solicitor can advise whether this is a reasonable course of action and how it may affect any future claim.

Where another contractor is engaged to complete or repair the work, you may be able to recover the cost of those works from the original builder. You may also be entitled to claim compensation for other financial losses directly resulting from the breach, such as the cost of temporary accommodation, storage charges, additional professional fees, or financing costs caused by lengthy delays.

If the builder has abandoned the project altogether, it may be necessary to establish whether they have fundamentally breached the contract, whether they remain entitled to any payment and what additional costs you have incurred in appointing replacement contractors.

Not every dispute needs to be resolved in court. Many are settled through negotiation or alternative dispute resolution, such as mediation, which can often achieve a quicker, cheaper outcome. However, if a settlement cannot be reached, court proceedings may become necessary.

Before issuing a claim, parties are generally expected to comply with the relevant pre-action protocols, including exchanging information about the dispute and exploring whether it can be resolved without litigation. Our solicitors can guide you through these requirements and ensure your position is protected throughout.

How a solicitor can help

Building disputes often involve a combination of legal, technical and practical issues. Our solicitors can assess the strength of your case, explain your legal rights and advise on the most appropriate strategy from the outset.

For further information, please contact Lewis Hudd in the civil litigation team on 01291 639280 or via email to lewis.hudd@feakes-legal.com.

Make a
Free
Enquiry